On this page
The short version
- EU brokers cannot use bonuses to attract retail clients: MiFID II Article 24(9) treats paying or receiving inducements as a breach of the firm's best-interest duty.
- ESMA's 2018 CFD measures directly prohibited monetary and non-monetary benefits — bonuses, gifts, trading tutorials and cost giveaways — and national regulators made these restrictions permanent from 2019–2020.
- Information and research tools are the defined exception; operational costs like settlement and exchange fees sit outside the ban.
- A deposit bonus is conditional credit, not a gift: volume requirements mean the cost of trading can consume much of the bonus value, as a labeled illustrative example shows.
- A large bonus signals which regulatory regime a broker operates under, not generosity — check the terms and jurisdiction before depositing.
If you browse forex broker sites long enough, you will notice a pattern: brokers regulated in the European Union almost never offer a deposit bonus, while some offshore-facing brokers advertise "50% welcome bonuses" prominently on their homepages. That difference is not a marketing strategy or a coincidence. In the EU, offering bonuses to retail CFD and forex clients is effectively prohibited — first by a broad inducements ban in the MiFID II rulebook, and then by a specific product-intervention rule that directly targeted CFD bonuses in 2018.
This article explains what those rules actually say, why regulators saw bonuses as harmful rather than generous, what EU-regulated brokers can still legitimately offer, and how to read a bonus offer on its own terms when you encounter one.
What a deposit bonus is — and why brokers offer one
A deposit bonus is a promotional payment added to your trading account when you deposit: deposit $1,000, receive $500 of bonus credit, and trade with $1,500 of "funds". The bonus is typically the broker's own money, credited to your account balance rather than to your pocket. Its job is to get you to fund an account, to make your balance look larger, and — because bonuses always come with conditions — to keep you trading.
That last part is the key to understanding the regulation. Bonus credit is almost always subject to conditions: you cannot withdraw the bonus (and sometimes anything, including your deposit) until you generate a required amount of trading volume. The bonus is therefore not a gift; it is a commitment device that ties you to trading activity.
The first layer: the MiFID II inducements ban
The EU's core investment-services rulebook, MiFID II (Directive 2014/65/EU), contains a general ban on inducements. Article 24(9) states that investment firms "are regarded as not fulfilling their obligations" — that is, they are treated as acting in breach of their best-interest duty — where they "pay or are paid any fee or commission, or provide or are provided with any non-monetary benefit in connection with the provision of an investment service or an ancillary service, to or by any party except the client".
In plain terms: a firm cannot use payments or benefits to influence how investment services are provided, to anyone, except the client themselves. A deposit bonus offered to a client is a payment connected to the provision of a service, so it sits squarely in the path of this rule.
The article does contain two narrow exceptions. A payment or benefit is allowed only if it:
is designed to enhance the quality of the relevant service to the client, and
does not impair the firm's duty to act honestly, fairly and professionally in the client's best interest — and its existence, nature and amount must be clearly disclosed before the service is provided.
Article 24(9) also carves out payments "which enables or is necessary for the provision of investment services", such as custody costs, settlement and exchange fees, regulatory levies or legal fees — operational costs that by their nature cannot create conflicts with the client's interests. A bonus is not in that category. Nothing about a promotional credit is necessary to deliver the trading service.
MiFID II extends the same logic inside the firm: Article 24(10) prohibits remuneration, sales targets or other arrangements that could give staff an incentive to recommend one instrument when a different one would better meet the client's needs. The principle is consistent — selling pressure should not be subsidized by payments or perks.
The second layer: ESMA's 2018 bonus prohibition for CFDs
In 2018, the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) used its new product-intervention powers to restrict the sale of CFDs to retail clients across the EU. Alongside the widely reported leverage caps and margin-closeout rules, the measures included a direct prohibition on incentives.
ESMA's later opinion on Spain's CNMV measures describes what the 2018 measures established and why: "the intervention measures established by ESMA in 2018 … include the prohibition to provide to retail clients any payment, monetary or excluded non-monetary benefits." In its considerations, ESMA noted that a common feature of the CFD industry's former marketing was "offering trading (monetary and non-monetary) benefits, such as bonuses to attract and encourage retail clients to invest in CFDs, the offer of gifts (for example holidays, cars, electronic goods), trading tutorials or reduced costs (for example lower spreads or fees)."
Two definitional details are worth noting:
"Excluded non-monetary benefits" — the benefits that remain banned — are defined as any non-monetary benefit other than information and research tools. So cash-like credit and physical perks are out; analytical resources are the exception.
Training offers are treated as inducements too. ESMA restricted trading tutorials as marketing benefits, and Spain's CNMV went further in 2023: in its measures, "the general offer of free training, the use of demo accounts and webinars, is not permitted" as a marketing practice aimed at attracting new retail clients, alongside a ban on CFD advertising communications and event sponsorship.
ESMA's 2018 measures were temporary (product-intervention measures can run for three months and be renewed). Between 2019 and 2020, EU national regulators adopted their own permanent versions, as ESMA's Investor Corner explains, "ensur[ing] the continued protection of retail investors". This is why the ban persists today as national law across the EU — and why some regulators, like the CNMV in 2023, have continued to widen it.
What EU-regulated brokers can still offer
The rules do not forbid every benefit. What survives:
Information and research tools. Market commentary, charting, economic calendars, educational libraries — these are the defined exception to the non-monetary-benefits ban.
Benefits that genuinely enhance service quality, do not impair the best-interest duty, and are clearly disclosed before the service is provided. That is a high bar, and it is why you see disclosure documents rather than promo codes at EU-regulated firms.
Operational necessities such as settlement and exchange fees, which sit outside the ban because they cannot create conflicts.
Note the asymmetry with ordinary commerce. A supermarket loyalty point is fine; an inducement attached to a regulated investment service is not, because regulators judged that the bonus effectively pays the client into a product whose risks the client is not positioned to bear.
When you do see a bonus: reading the terms
Outside the EU's regime, bonus offers still exist, and their terms follow a familiar arithmetic. It is worth doing the calculation before treating any bonus as free money. The following is an illustrative example with assumed terms — not an observation of any specific broker:
Suppose a broker offers a 50% bonus on a $1,000 deposit, with a trading-volume requirement of 0.5 standard lots for every $10 of bonus. The bonus is $500, so the requirement is 25 standard lots of completed trades. On EUR/USD with a USD account, one pip on one standard lot is conventionally $10; at a 1.0-pip effective spread, one round-turn per standard lot costs $10 in spread. Completing 25 lots therefore costs about $250 in spread alone — half the bonus — before any profit or loss from price movement, and while your withdrawal may remain blocked until the volume target is met. (Computed: 25 lots × $10 = $250, which is 50% of the $500 bonus.)
The exact numbers vary by broker, and requirements are often expressed differently (multipliers on deposit plus bonus, or volume per dollar). The structure, however, is consistent: the bonus raises the amount you must trade, and the cost of trading that volume comes out of your own funds. Whether the bonus helps you or the broker depends on numbers like these — and on whether you can withdraw your deposit independently of the bonus terms.
The warning regulators attach
ESMA's investor-education materials go further than the ban itself. The Investor Corner's frauds-and-scams guidance lists "too-good-to-be-true offers" among the classic tactics of investment scammers: "Offers that include discounts, bonuses, or claims of a unique opportunity are often tactics used by scammers. Such offers are designed to create a sense of urgency and to lure into quick investments."
That is a fair description of the incentive problem at every level of the market: bonuses create urgency, urgency shortens decision-making, and shortened decision-making is where unsuitable products get sold. Unregulated operators borrow the look of legitimate promotions; regulated EU firms are barred from using the tactic at all.
What this means when comparing brokers
Keep three things separate.
First, "no bonus" is not a fee. An EU-regulated broker's refusal to offer a bonus is compliance, not stinginess. Judge brokers on what the other BrokerVS articles cover — total cost, execution, and regulatory standing — not on promotional credit.
Second, jurisdiction explains the difference. The inducements ban and the CFD incentive prohibition are EU-law constructs. Other jurisdictions have different rules, and some permit or simply have no specific prohibition on bonuses. Seeing a large deposit bonus tells you something about which regulatory regime a broker is operating under — it does not by itself tell you the broker is unsafe, but it does mean the protections described in this article do not apply to that offer, and it shifts the burden of checking the terms onto you.
Third, a bonus is the broker's money until conditions are met. Read the withdrawal conditions before depositing: whether the bonus is withdrawable, whether your deposit is also locked by the volume requirement, and what happens to open positions if the bonus is removed.
Limits of this article
The rules described are the EU regime for retail clients: MiFID II inducement rules for investment services generally, and product-intervention measures for CFDs. Professional clients, other products, and other jurisdictions are governed differently, and this article does not attempt to survey them.
Regulation is a floor, not a guarantee: compliance with the inducements ban does not make a broker or an investment suitable for you.
Numbers in the bonus-terms section are a labeled illustrative example with assumed terms; they are not data from any real broker.
This article is education, not legal or financial advice. For a specific broker's terms, the governing documents are the broker's own legal terms and its regulator's rules.
Sources & further reading
Check the original source for its scope, publication date and latest terms.
- Directive (EU) 2014/65/EU (MiFID II), Article 24https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CELEX:32014L0065
- ESMA opinion on product intervention measures on CFDs proposed by CNMV (ESMA35-335435667-4345)https://www.esma.europa.eu/sites/default/files/2023-07/ESMA35-335435667-4345_Opinion_on_product_intervention_measures_on_CFDs_and_other_high_risk_products_proposed_by_CNMV.pdf
- ESMA Investor Corner — Product Interventionhttps://www.esma.europa.eu/investor-corner/product-intervention
- ESMA Investor Corner — Frauds and Scams
For education and research, not personal investment advice. Trading involves risk. Broker terms and protections depend on your country, account and contracting legal entity.



